top of page

What Sets Chianti and Super Tuscan Apart: Decoding the World of Italian Wines

Updated: Oct 31

Italian wines have long enchanted wine lovers across the globe. Among the most celebrated styles are Chianti and Super Tuscan wines. Both originate from the picturesque Tuscany region, known for its breathtaking landscapes and rich history, as well as its exceptional winemaking. So, what distinguishes these two beloved wine styles? Let’s explore the unique qualities and characteristics of Chianti and Super Tuscan wines.


The Heart of Chianti


Chianti represents much more than a wine; it embodies a deep-rooted tradition that spans centuries. The Chianti wine zone, located in central Tuscany, is among Italy's most iconic and highly regarded wine-producing areas.


Chianti’s origins trace back to the 13th century, originating from small-scale local production. Its journey reached a significant milestone in 1967 when the Denominazione di Origine Controllata (DOC) system was established to standardize its production.


Typically, Chianti wines are made primarily from the Sangiovese grape, often blended with smaller varieties like Canaiolo and Colorino. On average, Chianti wines contain about 75% - 95% Sangiovese.


Chianti is known for its bright acidity and fruity flavor, often highlighted by notes of cherry, plum, and herbs. It pairs beautifully with a range of dishes, but is especially popular with pasta, tomato sauces, and traditional Tuscan fare. A classic pairing is a Chianti with Spaghetti Pomodoro, where the wine's acidity complements the tangy tomato sauce perfectly.


Understanding Chianti Classico


A distinguished sub-region within Chianti is Chianti Classico, known for producing wines that generally exhibit superior quality compared to the larger Chianti designation.


Chianti Classico is regulated by strict guidelines, requiring that wines contain at least 80% Sangiovese. It must come from the designated Classico sub-region, which is symbolized by the famous black rooster seal.


The flavor profile of Chianti Classico tends to be richer and more complex, showcasing deeper flavors of blackberry, cherry, leather, and spice. These wines also have excellent aging potential, often developing even more nuanced characteristics over time. For instance, wines from the 2015 vintage, which benefitted from ideal weather conditions, continue to impress critics for their structure and age-worthiness.


A bottle of Chianti Classico wine in a rustic setting
Chianti Classico - A Classic Representation of Italian Terroir

What Are Super Tuscans?


Super Tuscan wines emerged in the 1970s as a response to the strict Italian wine classification system. Forward-thinking winemakers in Tuscany desired to create high-end wines that allowed for experimentation with different grape varieties and blends.


While “Super Tuscan” is not an official classification, it has become a widely recognized term describing these innovative wines. They often incorporate non-native grape varieties such as Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, and Syrah blended with Sangiovese.


Super Tuscan wines are celebrated for their bold and rich flavor profiles, often reflecting deep black fruits, chocolate notes, and a plush mouthfeel. For example, the acclaimed Sassicaia, a Super Tuscan wine, is noted for its complex layers of dark fruit and spice, earning its place among the world's finest.


The Evolution of Super Tuscans


The rise of Super Tuscans marked a transformative moment in Italian wine history. Pioneers like Tenuta San Guido with Sassicaia and Marchesi Antinori with Tignanello led the way, quickly gaining a loyal following among wine critics and collectors.


These premium wines challenged existing regulations and fueled a new wave of wine innovation. Today, numerous winemakers have embraced the artistic license to craft bold, unique blends, continuing to reshape Tuscany’s wine culture.


Comparing the Terroirs


Terroir—the combination of soil, climate, and environment—deeply influences the characteristics of Chianti and Super Tuscan wines.


Chianti Terroir


Chianti's landscape is defined by diverse geological features and climatic conditions. The region's hilly terrain, along with a mix of soils such as clay, limestone, and sandstone, creates an environment perfectly suited for growing Sangiovese.


With hot summers and mild winters, Chianti enjoys a long growing season, which contributes to grape complexity and acidity. This harmonious balance is crucial in yielding the crisp, vibrant profiles synonymous with Chianti wines.


Super Tuscan Terroir


Conversely, Super Tuscan producers often have the freedom to select prime vineyard sites ideal for their chosen varietals. While many continue to use Sangiovese, international grapes like Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot allow for greater creative expression and variation.


This flexibility permits winemakers to explore a more extensive range of terroirs, resulting in opulent and fruit-forward styles that stand in contrast to the traditional Chianti profile. Many Super Tuscans also come from lower elevations, which can further affect the wine’s personality.


The Importance of Regulations


A significant difference between Chianti and Super Tuscans lies in the regulations dictating their production.


Chianti Regulations


Chianti wines must adhere to strict rules enforced by the DOC and DOCG (Denominazione di Origine Controllata e Garantita) classifications. These regulations cover grape varieties, production techniques, aging durations, and labeling standards.


For instance, Chianti requires a minimum of 70% Sangiovese, with blends including a range of other local and international varietals. Additionally, certain aging requirements ensure the wine is developed adequately before release.


Super Tuscan Freedom


In contrast, Super Tuscans fall under the “IGT” (Indicazione Geografica Tipica) classification, offering winemakers more creative freedom. This classification permits the exploration of different grapes, blending techniques, and production styles unhindered by traditional rules.


Despite less stringent oversight, many producers show a commitment to quality, resulting in exceptional wines crafted to high standards.


Food Pairings: Chianti vs. Super Tuscan


When considering food pairings, Chianti and Super Tuscans shine in their own ways, thanks to their unique flavor profiles.


Chianti Pairings


Chianti’s vibrant acidity makes it an excellent partner for diverse dishes. Some classic pairings include:


  • Pasta with Tomato Sauce: The wine complements the acidity of the tomatoes, creating a balanced flavor.

  • Pizza: A classic Margherita pizza gets a delightful lift from the wine's fruity notes.

  • Grilled Meats: The wine's tannins enhance the smoky flavors of grilled fare like ribeye steak.


Super Tuscan Pairings


Super Tuscans, rich and bold, excel with hearty meals. Consider these pairings:


  • Steak and Lamb Dishes: The robust flavors of Super Tuscans match well with well-seasoned meats.

  • Rich Pasta Dishes: Full-bodied Super Tuscans bring out the best in ragù or creamy pasta sauces.

Price Point and Accessibility


Both Chianti and Super Tuscan wines cater to a variety of budgets, showcasing significant differences in pricing.


Chianti Pricing


Chianti often provides excellent value, with many high-quality bottles priced under $20. This makes it an approachable choice for both casual wine drinkers and enthusiasts. Some popular Chianti labels, like Ruffino and Fetzer, are commonly found at this price point.


Super Tuscan Pricing


Super Tuscans typically command higher prices due to their premium grapes and limited production. Renowned options like Sassicaia or Tignanello can range from $50 to several hundred dollars per bottle. This makes them luxurious selections for collectors and serious wine lovers.


The Ongoing Debate: Wine Purists vs. Innovators


The conversation surrounding Chianti and Super Tuscans often ignites passionate opinions among wine enthusiasts. Traditionalists argue that Chianti epitomizes Tuscany's historical essence, underscoring its significance and defined characteristics.


Conversely, supporters of Super Tuscans relish the creativity they represent, embodying Tuscany's dynamic wine culture. This debate highlights the beauty of the wine world and reveals the richness of styles that can thrive within one region.


Embracing the Journey of Tuscan Wines


Both Chianti and Super Tuscan wines provide a captivating view into the tradition and innovation that define Tuscany's winemaking. Each possesses its own distinct character, offering unique flavor profiles, terroir influences, and pairing options.


Chianti serves as a testament to enduring Italian winemaking traditions, while Super Tuscans embody the adventurous spirit of change and exploration. Whether you are drawn to the classic charm of Chianti or the luxurious elegance of Super Tuscans, one thing is certain: both wine styles contribute significantly to the vibrant tapestry of Tuscany's wine heritage.


As you embark on your exploration of Italian wines, allow your palate to guide you. Dive into the unique flavors of Chianti and Super Tuscan wines, and celebrate the artistry found in every bottle. Cheers to the enchanting wines of Tuscany!

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page