Search

Varieties of Italian Rice: Arborio, Vialone Nano, and More. by master Chef Gianluca Deiana Abis

Jan 274 min read

Lush green rice plants sway gently in the warm sun, their grains almost ready for harvest in a vibrant paddy field.

Italian cuisine is renowned for its rich flavors, fresh ingredients, and heartwarming dishes. Central to the culinary landscape, especially in northern Italy, is rice. Varieties like Arborio and Vialone Nano are cherished not just for their taste but for the unique textures they bring to the table. This article explores the fascinating world of Italian rice, detailing the distinctions between these popular types and offering pertinent advice for their best use.

The Importance of Rice in Italian Cooking

In Italy, rice is not merely a side dish; it is essential to signature dishes like risotto. The grain was introduced from Asia during the Middle Ages and successfully flourished in regions like the Po Valley. Today, Italian rice varieties are celebrated for their high starch content, which is vital for that desired creamy consistency in risottos. The choice of rice can dramatically shift the texture, flavor, and overall experience of a dish.

Overview of Italian Rice Varieties

While Italy cultivates many types of rice, the most notable ones include Arborio, Carnaroli, and Vialone Nano. Each variety has unique characteristics that lend themselves to specific culinary uses.

1. Carnaroli

Characteristics: Medium-grain rice with a high starch content. It has a firm structure and the ability to absorb a lot of liquid while remaining al dente.
Uses: Carnaroli is considered the "king of risotto rice" in Italy because of its superior ability to create a creamy texture without losing its shape.
Best For: Luxury risottos with rich ingredients like saffron, porcini mushrooms, or seafood.
Region: Grown mainly in northern Italy, especially in the Po Valley (Lombardy and Piedmont).

2. Vialone Nano

Characteristics: A smaller, rounder grain than Carnaroli, with a slightly softer texture. It absorbs liquid quickly, which makes it perfect for creamy risottos.
Uses: Preferred for lighter, more delicate risottos, particularly in Veneto, such as Risotto al Tartufo (truffle risotto) or Risotto all’Amarone.
Best For: Soupy or wetter risottos, where the rice's natural starch helps create a velvety consistency.
Region: Grown in the Veneto region, where it’s highly prized for its versatility.

3. Arborio

Characteristics: The most commonly available risotto rice outside of Italy. It has a larger grain and slightly lower starch content compared to Carnaroli and Vialone Nano, making it easier to overcook.
Uses: Ideal for beginners learning to make risotto because it’s widely available and forgiving when cooked, though it doesn't yield as creamy a texture as Carnaroli.
Best For: Basic risottos or recipes where creaminess is less critical.
Region: Originally from Arborio, a town in Piedmont, but now widely grown elsewhere.

4. Baldo

Characteristics: Similar to Carnaroli but slightly less creamy and more delicate. Baldo rice is short-grain and holds its shape well. It’s known for quick cooking times.
Uses: Ideal for pilaf-style dishes or drier risottos, as it doesn't break down as easily.
Best For: Modern or experimental risottos where texture matters more than creaminess.
Region: Grown in northern Italy, particularly in Piedmont and Lombardy.

5. Arlechino

Characteristics: A less common rice variety, Arlechino is a hybrid with similar traits to Vialone Nano. It has a good balance between creaminess and firmness.
Uses: Excellent for regional risottos where the rice needs to stand up to bold flavors.
Best For: Local and niche Italian dishes, or where balance in texture is essential.
Region: Found in smaller rice-growing areas of Italy, primarily used in regional cuisine.

6. Roma

Characteristics: A large-grain rice that absorbs flavors well but tends to become very soft and creamy, making it less suitable for al dente risottos.
Uses: Better for soups or baked dishes where creaminess and softness are desired.
Best For: Thick soups, rice puddings, or baked risottos.
Region: Cultivated in the Lazio region, especially around Rome.

7. Maratelli

Characteristics: A short-grain rice with moderate starch content. It offers a balance between creaminess and firmness.
Uses: Traditional risottos and regional dishes, particularly those cooked in broths.
Best For: Rustic risottos or dishes with bold, hearty flavors.
Region: Originated in Piedmont but less widely grown today.

Key Differences:

Rice Type	Grain Size	Starch Content	Creaminess	Structure	Typical Use
Carnaroli	Medium	High	Very Creamy	Al Dente Texture	Luxury risottos, saffron risotto
Vialone Nano	Small	High	Creamy	Softer Texture	Soupy or delicate risottos
Arborio	Large	Moderate	Moderately Creamy	Can Overcook	Basic risottos, beginner-friendly
Baldo	Short	Moderate	Less Creamy	Firm	Pilaf, dry risottos
Arlechino	Medium	High	Balanced Creaminess	Firm	Regional dishes
Roma	Large	Moderate	Very Creamy	Soft	Soups, baked risottos
Maratelli	Short	Moderate	Balanced	Firm	Rustic risottos, broths

The Three Key Steps to Making Risotto:

Tostatura (Toasting)
- Toast the rice in a hot pan with oil or butter before adding liquid. This seals the grains, helps maintain their structure, and enhances the final texture.
Bagnatura (Wetting)
- Gradually add hot stock, one ladle at a time, stirring frequently. This process allows the rice to slowly absorb the liquid, releasing its starch to create the risotto's creamy consistency.
Mantecatura (Creaming)
- Once the rice is cooked, remove it from the heat and stir in cold butter and grated Parmigiano Reggiano. This step enriches the dish and creates a luxurious, velvety finish.